By: Cynthia Rylant
This story struck me as an odd one and one I did not enjoy from Cynthia Rylant. Though the text is simple, there are deeper meanings within each chapter. Sometimes, I felt like I didn't understand what those "deeper meanings" were or should be. This didn't make me feel very confident since I am an adult reading a children's book. :-)
One element I did enjoy was the quaint coziness of the cafe. This reminds me of a local dive my whole family ventures to about once or twice a week. We know all the waiters and waitresses, even the owners. Everyone is friendly and the waiters know our exact order-if we decide to order our "regular." It's very comforting and relaxing to be able to go in a public place and feel this comfortable and at home. This is how the cafe makes me feel.
After reading this story, I was left with some questions. So, maybe some of my colleagues can help me out. Again, I almost feel a little ridiculous that I, a competent English-major, cannot see behind the simple text and figure out if there are issues more pertinent. What's the overall message, if any? Is there a deeper meaning to the story other than the cafe being magical? What does all this magic mean?
As you can see, I'm left with questions. Despite the questions I have, I did not enjoy the story. This has been my very least favorite from Cynthia Rylant. Currently, I'm reading Missing May and am thoroughly enjoying that one.
1 comment:
I am sorry that you did not enjoy this one. I did not know what to think of the story when I first read it either. I spent a couple of days pondering it. This is for me the kind of story I like best. To answer your question I would ask you to read my blog on the book. I would be very interested to know what my classmates think is the deeper meaning too. As for your families local diner, I know what you mean. We live in Gloucester and there are a couple of places like that. You go in and they know you, you are not just a stranger. I think these kinds of experiences are getting rarer by the day in this rush around world. I agree that it is a special feeling and I think Ms. Rylant would agree as well.
Post a Comment